This page has been moved to http://www.outdoorlife.com/blogs/gone-fishin
If your browser doesn’t redirect you to the new location, please visit The Gone Fishin' at its new location: www.outdoorlife.com/blogs/gone-fishin.
The Things I Miss Most About Fishing
A fishing reel is a fishing reel is a fishing reel. Right? Hell no! I can't ever forget when a company that used to sell the gear-shift mechanisms on "stingray" bicycles started to sell fishing reels in the United States. The reel was a Shimano Bantam (something-or-other-model-number).
However, it was silver-colored and had a rod to match. Bass Pro sold it...I gobbled it up and I still have it and use it. As I recall, it was the first baitcasting reel with a 'backlash-control' mechanism--and it worked pretty well. I've no clue how many largemouths I caught with it, but it was a ton. Before that, though, was the Garcia-Mitchell line of spinning reels.
First, there was the Garcia-Mitchell 300 and, as I recall, 300c which was left-handed. My brother opted for a 410, which was a totally awesome spinning reel. He used it. Abused it. And he still has it. Me? For my 8th grade graduation, I asked for a Garcia-Mitchell 440. This Cadillac of all reel featured an automatic bail. To cast, all you had to do was touch the bail, rear back, fire forward and take your finger off the bail---great reel. Later, I bought a 308 which was the ultralight version of all of the above--lots smaller. Every one of those spinning reels were built on the 300 base. What a reel. Are there any others really, really like it?—Gerry Bethge, Deputy Editor








I loved the Mitchell 308, 408 and 508(forked handle). I still have several of them and use the to fish for bream and shellcrackers on Lake George in Florida. I have a new Mitchell but I still like the old one the best.
Posted by: Bill Sampson | July 22, 2008 at 12:03 PM
Hey Bill---You might remember that those old Garcia-Mitchell's were manufactured in France. Seems as if the quality suffered once that ended. Hard to imagine a fishing reel holding up for 40-plus years isn't it?
Posted by: Gerry Bethge | July 22, 2008 at 04:59 PM
You'll laugh at this, but that reel, and a really cool old-school fiberglass spinning rod the color of ice, sit somewhere on the bottom of Kinzua Dam in Pennsylvania . . . down there with the big muskies and trout.
It floated down there back in the Seventies when the father of a friend gunned the boat one of my brothers sat in, and the rest (rod/reel right over the gunwhale) is history . . .
Posted by: Steve Hickoff | July 25, 2008 at 11:30 AM
How about the Garcia Mitchell 900. Big but it cast a mile.
Posted by: Larry | August 10, 2008 at 07:42 PM